50° Fair  ·  Home · Archives · Go Hogs! · Blogs · Videos · Contact Us Search: Go

Fayetteville, Ark.

logo2.gif

SPONSORS



ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Location: WholeHogSports > Story     |     TAGGED: football (5) , other conferences (1)

LIKE IT IS : Big 12 foolish to let BCS standings break tie

Published: Tuesday, December 02, 2008 PRINT E-MAIL

Don’t blame Oklahoma for being happy about going to the Big 12 Championship Game.

Don’t blame Texas for being upset that it is not going to the Big 12 Championship Game.

The problem is the Big 12 ’s fifth tiebreaker, which sends the highest-ranked team in the Bowl Championship Series standings to the conference championship game. Thanks to a consensus of six computers, it was the Sooners.

Technically, it was only four computers that ranked OU over UT, but for the sake of consistency, which there is very little of in the BCS, we’ll say six.

ADVERTISEMENT

Six computers that obviously didn’t watch when Texas beat Oklahoma 45-35 in Dallas, which is still a neutral site.

Six computers that don’t take into consideration the Longhorns ’ one and only defeat came on the road to Texas Tech with one second remaining to be played.

Six computers that could actually determine a rematch between Alabama and Florida for the national championship.

Oh yeah, want to see some scrambling ? Let Missouri beat Oklahoma in the Big 12 Championship Game and Florida squeak by Alabama in the SEC Championship Game on Saturday and some BCS folks might be praying for a computer crash.

Or at least a virus.

It is even possible that the computers could pit Texas and Oklahoma against each other in the BCS championship game, which would be the Dead Ratings Rivalry for Fox.

Forget the Oklahoma-Texas controversy for a moment and consider that of those six computers used for determining the BCS rankings, only two had undefeated Alabama with the top score.

Three gave the 25 points (most possible ) to Oklahoma, which (and it really can’t be stated enough ) lost to Texas by 10 points on a neutral field. Two others gave it 24 points. One computer gave Texas the top score.

Jeff Sagarin’s computer ranked Oklahoma, Texas and Texas Tech ahead of Alabama and Florida, in that order, which hints of a programming problem that favors the Big 12.

Even someone who reboots his computer at the first sign of a problem has to question the data that is being fed to the computers.

If the human vote (66. 6 percent of the equation ) were removed from the BCS formula, Oklahoma would be No. 1 and Texas No. 2, followed by Alabama, Texas Tech and Utah. Florida would be No. 6.

The Gators, like the Sooners, are playing their best football of the season, but the calendar is not supposed to be factored into the computer rankings.

There is no sense in even writing anything positive about a playoff; the colleges and universities went after the ESPN contract for the BCS games like Jesse James did a train.

ESPN will have the power until 2014, and there is no reason to believe some television entity won’t have the rights after that.

But the bottom line is that the BCS is flawed, and the Big 12 should never have allowed the BCS rankings to figure into its tiebreaker, without a head-tohead clause.

That’s what the SEC uses, and, just for the record, if the Big 12 had the same tiebreakers as the SEC, ACC or Conference USA, it would be Texas headed to the championship game with Missouri this weekend.

Oh, wait. The computers don’t care if Texas beat both Oklahoma and Missouri, the Big 12 championship teams.

None of this has anything personal to do with OU. The Sooners are very good.

Yes, late in the season they ran the score up, most likely in an effort to sway the human voters. The Harris poll, made up of former coaches, players and administrators and current and former media members, actually reversed its field this week and went with Texas ahead of Oklahoma.

Why ?

Its voters realized what the computers were going to do and tried a counterattack.

It didn’t work.

The computers computed that a team that lost by 10 points to another team with the same won-loss record should represent the Big 12 South in the championship game.

Shame on the BCS, and shame on the Big 12.

Share This:

   

More football Stories:

THE RECRUITING GUY : 3 UA recruits on display at all-star event

Arkansas football team still making noise

Independence Bowl banks on Big 12, SEC

LIKE IT IS : Chizik's approval rating gets lift with Malzahn

THE RECRUITING GUY : Moss\' Arkansas roots include tree-climbing uncle

Defensive tackle commits to UA

EXTRA POINTS : A special holiday trip through time for Hog fans

LIKE IT IS : Ho, ho, ho: Santa of sports in gift-giving mood

Horton heydays

DB wastes no time in signing with Hogs


More other conferences Stories:

Bumpas\' road sound, scenic

LIKE IT IS : SEC vs. Big 12 exactly what title game needed

LIKE IT IS : Heisman vote comes down to Big 12’s Big 3

LIKE IT IS : Big 12 foolish to let BCS standings break tie

LIKE IT IS : Altman mostly mum about his day on the hill

LIKE IT IS : Big 12, SEC prove they’re the best this season

Green to leave USC, eyes UA

THE RECRUITING GUY : Hogs, Cornhuskers in fight for junior college guard

Leathernecks prep without head coach

Out with old, in with new under Long



Yesterday's Most Popular

1. THE RECRUITING GUY : 3 UA recruits on display at all-star event

2. ARKANSAS RAZORBACKS VS. NO. 7 TEXAS LONGHORNS : 'A different animal'Pelphrey : Longhorns SEC-like

3. KNOCK ON WOOD : Hogs' new winning standard put to test tonight

4. LIKE IT IS : Texas' Barnes good at raising bar, eyebrows

5. Hogs, Horns renew rivalry with fresh faces


Today's Most E-mailed

1. Serving notice : Razorbacks drop Texas for second top-10 upset in a week

2. ARKANSAS 67, NO. 7 TEXAS 61 : Another UA power play

3. LIKE IT IS : Ugly game a thing of beauty to Arkansas fans

4. Fortson, Washington bounce back from first-half blues to propel Hogs

5. In the Lane

recent_blogs.jpg

Hogs a no-show in FoxSports.com's power rankings

Jan 07, 2009

Arkansas' two top-10 wins, a 12-1 record and the good vibes from national personalities like ESPN's Andy Katz and CBSSports.com's ...

[+] More of this author's blog

dots_under_blog.gif

Brandon Marcello

AUDIO: Pelphrey's post-game press conference

Jan 07, 2009

Arkansas coach John Pelphrey's press conference after the Hogs' 67-61 win over No. 7 Texas is now available for your listening pleasu ...

[+] More of this author's blog

dots_under_blog.gif

Brandon Marcello

Your Turn: What do you think of the Hogs?

Jan 07, 2009

After losing to Arkansas last night, Texas coach Rick Barnes made the comment that the Razorbacks belonged in the Big 12, not the SEC ...

[+] More of this author's blog

dots_under_blog.gif

Brandon Marcello

Live Game Blog: No. 7 Texas vs. Arkansas

Jan 06, 2009

Arkansas 67, No. 7 Texas 61 (FINAL) Arkansas played an entertaining se ...

[+] More of this author's blog

dots_under_blog.gif

Brandon Marcello

Setting the table: No. 7 Texas vs. Arkansas

Jan 06, 2009

Well, it's gameday again already. The Hogs will be attempting to knock off the second top 10 team in a week after just a 72-hour turnaround from a gam ...

[+] More of this author's blog

dots_under_blog.gif

Brandon Marcello

AP Top 25

Updated December 01

1. Alabama 12-0

2. Florida 11-1

3. Texas 11-1

4. Oklahoma 11-1

5. USC 10-1

6. Penn State 11-1

7. Utah 12-0

8. Texas Tech 11-1

9. Boise State 12-0

10. Ohio State 10-2

11. TCU 10-2

12. Ball State 12-0

13. Cincinnati 10-2

14. Oklahoma State 9-3

15. Georgia Tech 9-3

16. Oregon 9-3

17. Georgia 9-3

18. Boston College 9-3

19. Missouri 9-3

20. Brigham Young 10-2

21. Michigan State 9-3

22. Mississippi 8-4

23. Pittsburgh 8-3

24. Northwestern 9-3

25. Oregon State 8-4

Where will Arkansas' basketball season end?


NCAA Tournament

NIT

SEC Tournament

Vote

Arkansas Razorbacks' 2008 Basketball Schedule

Nov. 3

Campbellsville University (exh)

W 103-58

Nov. 6

Dillard University (exh)

W 108-80

Nov. 14

Southeastern Louisiana

W 91-87

Nov. 20

California-Davis

W 68-59

Nov. 22

@ Missouri St.

L 57-62

Nov. 26

@ South Alabama

W 79-77

Nov. 29

Florida A&M

W 86-61

Dec. 3

Texas Southern

W 80-61

Dec. 10

North Carolina Central

W 98-70

Dec. 17

Austin Peay

W 89-80

Dec. 20

Stephen F. Austin

W 67-51

Dec. 27

Northwestern St.

W 95-56

Dec. 30

Oklahoma

W 96-88

Jan. 3

@ North Texas

W 86-75

Jan. 6

Texas

W 67-61

Jan. 10

Mississippi St.

     7:05 pm

Jan. 14

@ Ole Miss

     7:00 pm

Jan. 17

@ Florida

     1:05 pm

Jan. 24

Auburn

     12:05 pm

Jan. 29

Alabama

     8:05 pm

Jan. 31

@ LSU

     4:00 pm

Feb. 4

Tennessee

     7:05 pm

Feb. 7

@ Mississippi St.

     2:05 pm

Feb. 11

@ Auburn

     7:00 pm

Feb. 14

Kentucky

     12:05 pm

Feb. 18

LSU

     7:05 pm

Feb. 21

@ South Carolina

     6:00 pm

Feb. 25

@ Alabama

     7:00 pm

Mar. 1

Georgia

     3:05 pm

Mar. 4

Ole Miss

     7:05 pm

Mar. 8

@ Vanderbilt

     1:05 pm